NHL Star Brady Tkachuk Suggests Leo Carlsson's Record $18 Million Offer Could Be a Steal

The hockey world is buzzing after the Philadelphia Flyers presented restricted free agent Leo Carlsson of the Anaheim Ducks with a substantial five-year offer sheet, reportedly valued at an average annual value (AAV) of $18 million. This significant financial commitment would establish Carlsson as the highest-earning player across the league, regardless of whether he ultimately joins Philadelphia or if Anaheim opts to match the offer.

Despite the record-setting figure, Florida Panthers captain Brady Tkachuk suggests that any team acquiring the 21-year-old center at an $18 million annual cap hit might actually secure a bargain.

Tkachuk Brothers Weigh In on Carlsson's Value

Brady, alongside his brother Matthew Tkachuk, a teammate on the Panthers, discussed the offer sheet on their podcast, "Wingmen," as the deadline for the Ducks to respond approaches.

"Eighteen million is not an overpay whatsoever," Brady Tkachuk asserted, with Matthew Tkachuk concurring. "Unbelievable; he comes as advertised. Eighteen million is probably going to be underpaid. That's how good this player is."

Tkachuk's assessment may prove accurate, particularly as the NHL's salary cap is projected to rise steadily. Future contract negotiations for emerging talents such as Macklin Celebrini of San Jose and Connor Bedard of Chicago could potentially see them command even higher annual values, making Carlsson's deal appear more modest in comparison over time.

Anaheim's Cap Conundrum

The primary challenge for the Ducks does not revolve around Carlsson's on-ice value at an $18 million annual salary; had General Manager Pat Verbeek doubted his worth, the offer sheet would likely not have reached this stage. Instead, Anaheim's predicament centers on its ability to accommodate such a substantial contract within its existing salary cap.

The strategic move by Flyers General Manager Danny Briere placed Anaheim in a difficult position. At the time the offer sheet was tendered, the Ducks possessed just under $18 million in projected cap flexibility. However, a subsequent re-signing of defenseman Pavel Mintyukov reduced their available cap space to approximately $9 million.

Furthermore, Anaheim must also factor in forthcoming contract extensions for other key restricted free agents, including Cutter Gauthier and Beckett Sennecke. These impending negotiations further complicate the decision to match Carlsson's offer, making it both more challenging and financially precarious.

The Ducks face a deadline of Friday to determine their course of action. Should they decline to match the offer, the Flyers would be required to provide Anaheim with a significant number of first-round draft selections as compensation.